Wedding Cakes

All of our wedding cakes are customized for you. Whether you are looking for an elaborate, fondant-covered specialty cake or a more traditional cake with fruit or cream filling, we have the perfect cake for your special day.

Specialty Cakes

If you want a cake that will wow your guests, we are the cake shop for you. We are always up to the challenge of creating a unique, elaborate design that will combine art with taste. Call us at our Evansville, IN, bakery today to see what we can create for you.


Need a sweet treat for a special Evansville event? Try a dozen of our creatively designed cupcakes! We can make any design, from pumpkins to the Cookie Monster; our team can make the perfect dozen for your next event.

Welcome to Pinch of Sugar

The premier specialty cake shop in Evansville, IN

It doesn’t matter what you’re looking for – delicious specialty cakes with gorgeous designs, fresh cookies, tasty cake pops or scrumptious cupcakes – Pinch of Sugar is Evansville’s favorite place for sweets.

Since 2011, Pinch of Sugar has served as Evansville’s most trusted bakery for specialty cakes. Customers have trusted us with everything from a few dozen cupcakes for a school event to elaborate, decorative, specialty cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, weddings and more. Our cookies, cupcakes, and gourmet 3D carved cakes are a must for any occasion.

Pinch of Sugar specializes in specialty cakes, specifically wedding cakes and birthday cakes. With 3D designs ranging from racecars to putting greens, our cakes are sure to impress any onlooker. All fondant is made in-house, making the cakes as delicious to taste as they are to look at.

Call us today and ask how we can create a specialty cake for your next event, or come by our Evansville, IN, bake shop to pick up some cookies or cake balls. No matter the occasion, there’s only one bakery for you – Pinch of Sugar.

If you are looking for cupcakes, cookies and cake balls, come on into our store to see what we have available! All of our specialty cakes are made to order, so unfortunately we do not have any in the shop for purchase. Please call today or stop by the shop to place your order.

Call us today at (812) 476-7650.